charming

I have been home for most of the day with NPR playing in the background while I study. I don't know how many times I have heard it mentioned today that Judge Alito's confirmation will not go as smoothly as Justice Roberts, because he's not as charming. Is that really such a big deal? I mean, certainly, John Roberts took the "Most Attractive Justice" title from...uh...well...well, he has the title now, but I really didn't think that played a role in the selection of a justice. Physical features are important for elected officials, but I thought appointed positions are based more on abilities and cronyism.